Connect with us

News

Model S Owner Endures Insurance Woes Over Repairs

Published

on

A minor accident turned into a major repair headache for this New York based Tesla owner.

A minor accident turned into a major repair headache for this New York based Tesla owner. (Source: Standard Code)

Last month, a Tesla Model S owner documented a small accident in Midtown Manhattan and surprised the TMC discussion board by revealing that his car was to be declared a total-loss by his insurance company, Costco Insurance Agency. The damage occurred to the outside of the wheel-well, the tire and the certified shop also claimed some damage to the suspension, see image above.

From the surface, it looked to be a small amount of work but the total bill after being sent to a certified Tesla repair shop was $30,000, which included $10,000 in parts and $20,000 in labor. The kicker was that Costco Insurance initially decided they’d rather declare the car a total loss than pay $30k+tax for repair.

So the discussion on the board turned to replacement value with his insurance company and this is where the frustration started. The owner documented the back-and-forth with his insurance company and realized that it would be quite a financial hit with the replacement option. The owner originally paid $104,000 for Model S85 and received it in December 2013.

According to the owner, the insurance company had no Kelly Blue Book value to lean on and wielded its own internal formula for the car’s value. The Tesla discussion board and owner calculated a $75,000 replacement value for his year-old car, which included sales tax. The owner, known as standardcode, was not really happy with that amount due to his financing, which had him on the hook for another $70,000 US Bank for the car. There was a lot of discussion on depreciation and commenters felt the depreciate in this case was pretty accurate.

The thread generated many other related topics. Some discussion centered around the owner’s initial frustration with Tesla’s pre-paid service agreement that’s not transferrable to another car or owner. However, the owner said that after talking with Tesla Motors during this process that they would prorate his agreement to his next purchase.

Also, others mentioned on the board that other luxury cars would not have been totaled due to such a small amount of bodywork, but some pointed out that a new Model S means the ability to add recently added features (can you say P85D).

Advertisement
TESLARATI MARKETPLACE LIMITED-TIME OFFER

Give the gift of Tesla upgrades.

Shop for someone else or treat yourself. Get more shopping power with a Teslarati gift card.

YOU PAY $250
+
FREE BONUS $75
$325 TOTAL VALUE
Digital gift card delivered by email. Promotional terms apply.
View gift card details →

Throughout December 2014, we have been talking with standardcode and found out the ordeal was still fluid and the insurance company was reconsidering (Clean Technica reported it was a done deal). Early this month, standardcode told me that Ameriprise reconsidered and did pay for the repairs that came to $35,000.

In an email to Tesla Motors this month, the owner wrote, “the body shop was obviously good at what they do and they communicated well too. They even sent me pictures of the work constantly. Having said that I still think $35,000 to repair the damage my car had is very high and I do still think that Tesla as a company needs to worry about the full ownership lifecycle including repairs etc.”

He went on to write, “All in all, I recognize that it was Ameriprise that caused me the headaches here and wasted a lot of my time.”

Standardcode picked up his repaired car in early January and mentioned “the most important lesson I learned is to have better insurance with replacement value. I guess there’s some legal risk to it but I’d have appreciated advice on which insurance is best when I first purchased the car.”

This tale, to me, is all about growing pains for a low-volume automaker. There’s been discussion about the car’s aluminum body as a reason for the high cost for parts and also the lack of certified Tesla body shops at this point for driving up repair costs? In Chicago, there’s only one certified body shop in the metro area.

Advertisement
TESLARATI MARKETPLACE LIMITED-TIME OFFER

Give the gift of Tesla upgrades.

Shop for someone else or treat yourself. Get more shopping power with a Teslarati gift card.

YOU PAY $250
+
FREE BONUS $75
$325 TOTAL VALUE
Digital gift card delivered by email. Promotional terms apply.
View gift card details →

What about your experiences? What has your experience been like with insurance companies and certified repair shops?

Addendum:
taurusking via the TMC discussion board mentioned that State Farm , AllState and Geico were top rated but the website did not specify by region. I switched from Geico ( was very happy with their customer service ) mainly because Liberty Mutual offers Better Car Replacement pkg.

"Grant Gerke wears his Model S on his sleeve and has been writing about Tesla for the last five years on numerous media sites. He has a bias towards plug-in vehicles and also writes about manufacturing software for Automation World magazine in Chicago. Find him at Teslarati

Advertisement
Comments

News

Tesla’s Cybercab fleet just had its biggest day ever

Tesla registered a record 200 Cybercabs in one day, and Dallas could be next up.

Published

on

By

Tesla added a record 200 Cybercabs to its Texas Robotaxi fleet in a single day, pushing the purpose-built two-seater past 750 registered units in the state. The batch landed on the Texas Department of Motor Vehicles automated vehicle register at 3:45 p.m. CT on November 17 and included 200 Cybercabs and one Model Y. Tesla’s Cybercab count had sat at 573 since late October before the jump.

The additions also put Tesla back ahead of Waymo on the register. Tesla now has 1,507 vehicles registered for driverless operation in Texas against Waymo’s 1,321, a lead of 186. Waymo had been ahead by 15 vehicles before the batch arrived. Tesla first passed Waymo on November 10, as Teslarati reported, before Waymo briefly moved back in front.

Cybercabs now make up 51.3 percent of Tesla’s registered Texas fleet, at 773 units against 734 Model Ys. Waymo’s fleet in the state is split between 874 Jaguar I-PACEs and 447 Ojai vehicles.

The register does not say where vehicles will operate, and registration does not mean a car is carrying riders. Still, the timing lines up with Tesla’s plans for Dallas. On the company’s third quarter earnings call in October, AI chief Ashok Elluswamy said, “next month, we’ll be launching in Dallas,” and a video posted over the weekend showed more than 50 Cybercabs parked in rows at a Dallas lot, with more on a car carrier nearby. Tesla has not announced a start date.

Advertisement
TESLARATI MARKETPLACE LIMITED-TIME OFFER

Give the gift of Tesla upgrades.

Shop for someone else or treat yourself. Get more shopping power with a Teslarati gift card.

YOU PAY $250
+
FREE BONUS $75
$325 TOTAL VALUE
Digital gift card delivered by email. Promotional terms apply.
View gift card details →

Dallas is already one of Tesla’s busiest Robotaxi markets. Model Y Robotaxis there have run without anyone in the driver’s seat around the clock since November 11, and the city logged 608,130 miles with no safety monitor between January 22 and October 18, second only to Austin, according to Tesla’s first Robotaxi Safety Report. Public Cybercab rides have been limited to Austin since the vehicle joined the service in September.

The fleet growth comes as Tesla shifts more of its factory capacity toward the Cybercab. The company is winding down Cybertruck production at Giga Texas by the end of summer 2027 to make room, and announced this week a €3 billion expansion of Giga Berlin with a new building designed to produce up to 1 million Cybercabs a year starting in 2029, as Teslarati covered.

Some Cybercabs will soon go to private owners too. Tesla began inviting select customers to buy the vehicle for personal use last week at $29,990 with a required $299 monthly Autonomy Subscription, with deliveries targeted for December in the same five Texas cities where Robotaxi operates.

Continue Reading

News

Tesla Robotaxi takes over for Uber credits and loaners at Service locations

Published

on

Tesla is now utilizing its in-house Robotaxi platform to give those waiting for their vehicles during Service visits rides instead of offering Uber credits or Loaner vehicles.

Tesla owners in Austin who bring vehicles in for service are receiving in-app prompts to use the company’s Robotaxi network while their cars are being worked on.

One recent notification, sent during a frunk repair, carried the heading “Try Robotaxi During Your Service Visit” and stated that while the vehicle is being serviced, the customer can take an autonomous Robotaxi ride to the next destination in Austin and download the Robotaxi app to get started.

The suggestion arrives as Tesla has long relied on two main ways to keep customers mobile during longer service visits. Service centers have typically offered loaner vehicles drawn from a limited fleet; when those vehicles were unavailable, centers have issued Uber or Lyft credits. Uber credits were widely eliminated years ago, but some locations will still give them out.

Both approaches carry costs: loaner cars occupy inventory that could otherwise be sold, and third-party credits generate recurring expense.

Code discovered in Tesla app version 4.60.5 in September 2026 already listed “sv_transport_robotaxi” among the transportation options available for service appointments, alongside paid loaners and other alternatives, indicating the company had been preparing to route customers through its own autonomous fleet.

Your Tesla could be in the Robotaxi fleet next month, Elon Musk claims

Austin provides the clearest early example. The city remains Tesla’s primary Robotaxi market, with unsupervised Model Y and Cybercab vehicles operating across an expanded zone of roughly 400–440 square miles and running 24/7 since November 11. Public driverless service is also live in Dallas, Fort Worth, Houston, San Antonio, Miami, Orlando, and Tampa.

Directing service customers into this network keeps the vehicles utilized and reduces reliance on external rideshare credits, while giving owners practical experience with the Robotaxi app and vehicles during the repair window. Once service is complete, the same network can be used for the return trip without a staffed loaner handoff.

The Austin notification is the first public instance of the capability the September app code previewed. As Robotaxi expands into additional U.S. markets and the fleet grows, service centers in those cities are positioned to follow the same pattern, presenting autonomous rides as a primary transportation option during the service appointment rather than defaulting to loaner vehicles or third-party credits.

For customers, the change preserves mobility without the logistics of arranging a temporary car; for Tesla, it links the service operation more tightly to the expanding Robotaxi business.

Continue Reading

Elon Musk

Sean Duffy fires back at Elon Musk over free Starlink

Sean Duffy says the FAA picked a ground network over Starlink, and Musk isn’t impressed.

Published

on

By

Elon Musk and U.S. Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy during Duffy’s visit to Gigafactory Texas in May 2025. (Credit: Elon Musk/X)
Elon Musk and U.S. Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy during Duffy’s visit to Gigafactory Texas in May 2025. (Credit: Elon Musk/X)

Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy has responded to Elon Musk’s claim that the Federal Aviation Administration turned down free Starlink terminals before last week’s nationwide ground stop, saying the department chose a ground-based network after running into problems with an earlier version of the satellite service. Musk’s reply was a single emoji: “🤦‍♂️.”

Speaking at a press conference, Duffy said Starlink had been useful in some parts of the system. “I’ve worked well with Elon, and he, Starlink was a great solution for some of our assets in Alaska, but we sent Starlink, in one of its prior iterations, to our tech lab, and, there was some issues that we had to navigate, and we thought that the best method is to have a network that’s based on the ground,” Duffy said, according to a transcript published by ZeroHedge. “Now, I think what he’s doing with Starlink and the speed is remarkable, but, our airspace is very big. We have assets everywhere. And so, again, we used him for different parts of the airspace.”

Duffy did not dispute that the offer was made. He also did not say what problems the FAA found during testing.

The exchange started Monday, when Musk wrote on X, “Free Starlinks for FAA were offered to Sec Duffy, but he said they were not needed. As it turns out, they were,” as Teslarati reported. That post came three days after the FAA grounded departures nationwide on November 13, when its legacy equipment became unstable as data flooded its telecommunications network at 1,000 connection attempts every four to five seconds. The FAA traced the flood to a radar site in Amarillo, Texas, and a radio site in El Dorado, Arkansas, where L3Harris had been installing a new router. Roughly 12,462 flights were canceled that day.

Duffy has also signaled frustration with L3Harris, which runs the FAA’s current network. “I want to get away from L3Harris and get to a new one, but they own the network,” he said. “I can’t cancel the network that they own.” He has asked Congress for $50 billion to modernize air traffic control, arguing against “a patchwork, a fix to a system that’s critical for every single family.”

The FAA’s position on satellite links predates this week. In a July 2025 letter to lawmakers, FAA Administrator Bryan Bedford said the agency “would not use Starlink (or any satellite service) as the sole communications technology” for safety-critical air traffic services. Reuters reported at the time that the FAA was not considering replacing its L3Harris and Verizon contracts with Starlink. Verizon’s FAA Enterprise Network Services contract, awarded in 2023, is valued at up to $2.4 billion over 15 years.

Musk first pressed the issue in February 2025, while he was leading the Department of Government Efficiency, writing that “the Verizon system is not working and so is putting air travelers at serious risk” before correcting himself days later to blame L3Harris. SpaceX said at the time it was supplying Starlink kits to the FAA at no cost and had no intent to take over any existing contract.

Continue Reading